Garlic Butter Scallops Recipe (2024)

FAQs

Is it better to cook scallops in butter or oil? ›

Don't use olive oil to sear your scallops!

I recommend butter as the best option, but you can also use vegetable, canola, or grapeseed oil. The cooking times above are for sea scallops, not diver or bay scallops.

Scallops, like many other types of seafood, can have a mild fishy odor that some people find off-putting. Soaking scallops in milk before cooking can help alleviate this odor. Milk can neutralize or mask the fishy smell, resulting in a milder scent.

Because sea scallops have a chewier texture, searing them in a hot skillet is the simplest, most effective cooking method to achieving a crisp exterior and tender, just-firm texture within. Basting the scallops with butter helps finish cooking them and enhances browning, too.

Don't overcook them. To know when they're done, look for the golden crust and opaque flesh. If you put a fork into them at this point, it should glide in. If you have large scallops, slice them in half so that you can monitor whether they are cooked properly on the inside or not.

Give your scallops a quick rinse to remove any grit, then thoroughly pat dry with a few paper towels, as excess moisture will inhibit searing. For added insurance, you can dry your scallops in the fridge for an hour or two before cooking.

Let scallops sit at room temperature for 10 minutes while towels absorb moisture.

Make sure you wash in free running water for at least 10 minutes after shucking, rinsing & trimming to ensure all toxins are effectively removed.

Thankfully, we have you covered: Dry Your Scallops: We mentioned this before, but it bears repeating—be sure to dry your scallops before placing them on the pan. Season Them Before You Cook Them: You should sprinkle your salt and pepper onto your scallops before cooking, not during or after.

Serving size: 2-4 scallops make a 3oz portion. The "U" stands for “under,” denoting that these are the largest scallops available, with under 8, 10, or 12 per pound.

Scallops are done when they are opaque in the center and golden brown on the outside. They should be firm but buttery, not at all difficult to cut or chew through (via The Kitchn). Scallops only take a few minutes to sear, meaning that they can become overcooked very quickly.

Is it better to broil or pan sear scallops? ›

Generally, the best way to cook scallops is searing them. Seared scallops are cooked on the stovetop, usually in a cast iron skillet to get an excellent sear, using butter or oil to get them nice and crispy. The result is a crisp, golden brown exterior with a delicate balance of savory, tender scallops inside.

Many chefs feel that scallops are better simply sauteed in butter and herbs. Scallops also cook quickly at high heat. Dry sea scallops are perfect for searing, since they don't let go of moisture in a hot pan. Simply cook them in a lightly buttered, hot pan and serve.

What type of oil should you use to cook scallops? A light, neutral oil with a high smoke point. Extra virgin olive oil will begin to smoke immediately over high heat. Instead, reach for grapeseed oil, canola oil, or vegetable oil.

After searing a few batches, we determined that scallops are perfectly cooked when their centers reach 115 degrees. Because scallops are so small and are usually cooked over high heat, carryover cooking will add another 10 to 15 degrees, for an ideal final temperature of 125 to 130 degrees.

Scallops cook very quickly, so the best way to get a good sear is to start with a very hot pan. We recommend searing scallops in a stainless-steel or well-seasoned cast-iron skillet; beginners can start with a nonstick skillet, which provides extra insurance that your scallops won't stick or tear.

Salt both sides of the scallop and place presentation side down on a paper towel to dry out. This will help prevent it from sticking to the pan. Moisture usually means the scallop will stick. Use the mercury ball test / water test to know when the stainless steel pan is hot enough to add oil.

What type of oil should you use to cook scallops? A light, neutral oil with a high smoke point. Extra virgin olive oil will begin to smoke immediately over high heat. Instead, reach for grapeseed oil, canola oil, or vegetable oil.

Scallops are a low carb food and are a great source of protein. Cook them in a variety of ways – fry them, bake them or even broil them. Broiling is one of the best ways to cook fresh scallops. It's quick and easy and gives the scallops a nice sear while keeping them juicy on the inside.