I tried beef-stroganoff recipes from Robert Irvine, Ree Drummond, and Rachael Ray, and the best calls for pickles instead of mushrooms (2024)

Advertisem*nt

The ingredients for Irvine's recipe were classic.

Irvine's recipe was fairly simple.

His ingredient list included beef-stroganoff basics like sliced beef, wine, and mushrooms.

Advertisem*nt

The chef said to season the beef and set it aside.

Irvine called for bottom-round beef to be sliced, seasoned, and set aside.

The recipe said to use paprika, but I accidentally used smoked paprika. It slightly threw off the meat's flavor, so I recommend sticking with the original.

Advertisem*nt

The meat had to braise for a while.

The meat, mushrooms, and onions were braised in a combination of wine and broth.

Irvine said the meat should be fork-tender after 25 minutes, but it wasn't quite done, so I waited five more minutes.

Advertisem*nt

Irvine's sauce was made with horseradish and sour cream.

I removed the meat and mushrooms before adding sour cream and horseradish to the pan to make the sauce.

The aroma assured me that I was heading toward a classic stroganoff flavor.

Advertisem*nt

I loved the addition of horseradish in Irvine's recipe.

The ingredients were tossed together, served over egg noodles, and garnished with parsley.

I really enjoyed the flavor of this dish, especially the slight kick from the horseradish. Had another recipe not blown me away, I would've picked Irvine's as my favorite.

Drummond’s ingredient list included brandy.

Drummond's beef-stroganoff recipe was interesting because it included brandy in the sauce.

Advertisem*nt

I cubed and cooked the beef before setting it aside.

Drummond's recipe called for sirloin steak, which is a relatively affordable cut. Unlike the other recipes, she called for cubed beef instead of sliced beef.

I cooked the meat and set it aside before making my way through the rest of the recipe.

Advertisem*nt

I cooked down brandy and beef broth to create the base of the sauce.

Drummond's sauce was created by cooking mushrooms, carrots, and onions in brandy and beef broth until the liquid was reduced. She also said to add some cornstarch as a thickener.

Once that was done, I added Dijon mustard, sour cream, and the meat.

Even with the cornstarch, the sauce came out a little thinner than the others.

Advertisem*nt

The carrots added a nice pop of color, but I wasn't a fan of the overall flavor.

The finished dish looked relatively similar to Irvine's, but the carrots made Drummond's stand out.

Although I typically like brandy in recipes, it didn't work for me in this one. The flavor seemed a bit too strong compared to the Dijon mustard and sour cream.

Advertisem*nt

I went into Ray’s recipe with some skepticism because it omitted mushrooms.

To my surprise, Ray's beef-stroganoff recipe didn't call for mushrooms. Instead, she opted for cornichons, which are small, tart pickles.

Because of the swap, I was skeptical about how the final dish would turn out.

Advertisem*nt

Ray recommended making the sauce first.

The base of her sauce started with beef consommé, a condensed version of beef broth, which I'd never worked with before.

It had a thickness that slightly reminded me of gravy.

Advertisem*nt

The consommé mixture smelled like my favorite kind of stroganoff sauce.

Ray's recipe called for thickening the consommé by mixing it into a roux. From there, I added Dijon mustard and sour cream.

The mixture instantly smelled like the traditional stroganoff sauce I was used to, so I was excited to try it.

Advertisem*nt

I cooked the meat and onions before adding in the pickles.

Ray's recipe called for beef-tenderloin fillet, an extremely nice — and pretty pricey — cut of meat.

After slightly cooking the beef and onions, I added the pickles.

Advertisem*nt

Ray's dish was tender and the pickles were a great addition.

I placed the meat, pickles, and onions over egg noodles, poured the sauce on top instead of mixing it in, and garnished the dish with parsley.

Although I wouldn't have thought to use such a fancy cut of meat for beef stroganoff, I'm not sure I'll ever look back — it was tender and incredibly delicious.

I might add mushrooms if I made this again, but I wouldn't skip the pickles. They added an interesting crunch and sourness to the dish that I surprisingly enjoyed.

Advertisem*nt

Ray’s beef stroganoff was my favorite.

Although I enjoyed the diversity of the dishes, I liked Ray's the best. Given that it didn't include mushrooms (a staple stroganoff ingredient) and included sour pickles, this wasn't what I expected.

Ray's recipe was also so simple that even with prep, I was done in under 30 minutes, which is perfect for a weeknight meal.

If I make beef stroganoff again, I'll follow Ray's recipe and add sautéed mushrooms. But I'd also probably borrow the inclusion of horseradish from Irvine.

Click to check out the other celebrity-chef recipes we've put head-to-head so far.